Short Hills homes aren’t built like the rest of northern New Jersey. The steep pitches, wooded lots, and architectural details throughout neighborhoods like Knollwood, Old Short Hills Estates, and the Country Club section create roofing conditions that demand real experience not a crew that only knows how to run asphalt shingles on a flat colonial. When the work is done right, you’re not just getting a new roof. You’re getting long-term protection on a property that took years to build and maintain.
The climate here doesn’t do you any favors either. Essex County winters bring freeze-thaw cycles, heavy snow accumulation, and ice dam risk especially on the older, steeper-pitched homes that make up a significant portion of Short Hills’ housing stock. A roof that wasn’t installed with proper underlayment, ventilation, and ice-and-water shielding will show you the damage within a few seasons. The cost of fixing water intrusion in a finished basement or plaster ceiling far exceeds what it would have cost to do the job correctly the first time.
And if you’re thinking about selling, your roof is one of the first things a buyer’s inspector flags. In a market where homes move at $2 million and above, a questionable roof isn’t a negotiating chip it’s a deal-killer. Getting ahead of it protects your asking price and your timeline.
Proline Construction is a family-owned roofing and general contracting company that has been serving residential and commercial clients across northern New Jersey since 2018. We hold both GAF Preferred Contractor status and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status Owens Corning’s highest tier designation which means we can offer enhanced manufacturer warranties that most roofing companies in Essex County simply cannot. We’re also BBB Accredited with an A rating and have earned the Best of HomeAdvisor designation for more than five consecutive years.
When you call Proline, the owner personally comes out to assess your roof and give you a written estimate. That’s not standard in this industry. For homeowners in Short Hills where expectations are high and the stakes are real it means you’re talking to the person who is actually accountable for the outcome, not a salesperson who disappears after the contract is signed. Every job is backed by a full warranty, and we offer free, no-pressure consultations so you can understand exactly what your roof needs before committing to anything.
It starts with a free consultation where the owner walks your roof personally. For homes in Short Hills especially older properties in Glenwood, Deerfield-Crossroads, or along the historic streets near the Cora Hartshorn Arboretum that initial assessment matters more than most homeowners realize. Roofs on homes built in the 1920s through the 1950s can have layered systems, original decking, or non-standard flashing details that a quick visual from the driveway won’t catch. We look at the full picture before we quote anything.
Once we’ve assessed the roof, you get a clear, written estimate with everything itemized. No vague numbers, no verbal assurances. Because Millburn Township requires a construction permit for roof replacement work, we handle the permitting process as part of the job so there’s no gap in your records at resale and no compliance issue down the road. The permit fee runs $10 per $1,000 of estimated cost with a $65 minimum, and we make sure it’s pulled correctly before work begins.
On installation day, our crew works efficiently and finishes the job as promised most full replacements are completed in a single day. Before we leave, we run a magnetic nail sweep across your lawn, driveway, and surrounding areas to collect any debris. For properties with landscaping and outdoor spaces that took real investment to build, that step isn’t optional it’s just how the job should end.
Ready to get started?
Request a callback
Short Hills isn’t a one-material market. Depending on the age, style, and architectural character of your home, the right roofing solution could be architectural shingles, cedar shake, metal roofing, tile roofing, or a flat roof system for commercial or mixed-use properties. We install and replace all of them. If you have a cedar shake roof on an older home in the Mountaintop section and someone is trying to talk you into asphalt shingles because that’s what they know, that’s not honest advising it’s convenience for the contractor. You deserve a recommendation that fits your home, not their crew’s comfort zone.
For homeowners in Short Hills considering metal roofing, it’s worth knowing that a quality metal system can reduce energy costs by 10 to 40 percent relevant in a community where large homes carry large utility bills. Metal roofing also holds up significantly better under the freeze-thaw conditions that Short Hills sees every winter, and the longevity means you’re unlikely to face another replacement in your ownership window. For homes with tile or slate accents, we assess what’s repairable versus what needs full replacement and we give you an honest answer either way.
On the commercial side, we handle flat roof systems and commercial roofing projects for business properties in the Short Hills area. Every job residential or commercial comes with a full workmanship warranty and access to enhanced manufacturer warranties through our GAF and Owens Corning certifications. That’s documented protection, not a verbal promise.
Yes and it’s worth understanding exactly what that means before you hire anyone. Short Hills falls under Millburn Township’s jurisdiction, and the township requires a construction permit for roof replacement work. The good news is that a straight roof replacement is specifically listed as exempt from a separate zoning permit, so you won’t need zoning board approval. But the construction permit is still required, and the fee is calculated at $10 per $1,000 of estimated project cost, with a $65 minimum.
This matters more than most homeowners realize at the time of the project. If a contractor skips the permit to save time or cut costs, that gap will surface when you sell. Buyers’ inspectors and title searches flag unpermitted work, and it can complicate your closing or reduce your negotiating position on a home worth $2 million or more. We handle the permitting process as part of every job it’s not an add-on, it’s just how the work should be done.
The honest answer is that it depends on your home’s size, the materials you’re replacing, and what’s found once the old roof comes off. The average roof replacement in New Jersey runs somewhere between $11,500 and $30,000, but Short Hills homes tend to fall at the higher end of that range or above it. The homes here are larger than the state average, many feature premium materials like cedar shake or tile, and the architectural complexity of rooflines in neighborhoods like Old Short Hills Estates or Knollwood adds labor time that a simple gable roof doesn’t require.
It’s also worth factoring in that material costs are rising in 2025 due to tariff-related increases estimates suggest an average addition of around $3,150 to a standard replacement project nationally. If you’ve been sitting on a roof that needs work, waiting isn’t saving you money. A free estimate from us gives you a real, itemized number based on your specific home not a ballpark pulled from a calculator.
A lot of the homes in Short Hills were built between the 1920s and 1950s, and many of them were designed with materials and architectural details that standard asphalt shingles don’t replicate well. Cedar shake, slate, and tile were common on the original builds, and replacing them with the wrong material can affect both the home’s appearance and its value which matters in a market where buyers pay close attention to authenticity and quality.
For homes with existing cedar shake, a like-for-like replacement preserves the aesthetic and is often the right call for historically significant properties. Where shake isn’t practical or budget doesn’t support it, high-profile architectural shingles can be a reasonable alternative if they’re properly matched to the home’s character. For flat or low-slope sections, modified bitumen or TPO systems hold up well under New Jersey’s temperature swings. The key is getting an honest assessment from someone who knows these materials not a contractor who defaults to whatever they install most often. That’s exactly the kind of evaluation we bring to every estimate in Short Hills.
Ice dams are a real and recurring issue for Short Hills homeowners, particularly on the steeper-pitched roofs common throughout the community. They form when heat escaping from the attic melts snow on the upper part of the roof, and that water refreezes at the colder eaves creating a dam that forces water back up under the shingles. The damage often doesn’t show up immediately, which is why spring is the right time to get a roof assessed even if nothing looks obviously wrong from the ground.
Signs of ice dam damage include water staining on interior ceilings or walls near the roofline, lifted or cracked shingles along the lower edge of the roof, damaged gutters, and deteriorated flashing around chimneys or dormers. Homes built before modern ice-and-water shield installation standards became common practice are especially vulnerable. If your home is 30 or more years old and hasn’t had a full roof replacement, a post-winter inspection is a reasonable precaution not an upsell. We offer free consultations specifically for this kind of assessment.
For most residential roof replacements in Short Hills, the installation itself is completed in a single day. That said, the timeline from first call to finished job involves a few steps the initial estimate, material ordering, permit pulling through Millburn Township, and scheduling around weather. From the time you approve a written estimate, most projects are scheduled and completed within a reasonable window depending on the season and current workload.
Spring and early summer tend to be the busiest seasons for roof replacements in Essex County, as homeowners coming out of winter discover damage from ice, snow load, and freeze-thaw cycling. If you’re planning a replacement before selling your home which is a smart move in Short Hills’ competitive real estate market getting on the schedule earlier in the season gives you more flexibility. Fall is also a good window before the first freeze, when conditions are stable and the work can be done without weather-related delays. We communicate clearly throughout the process so you know exactly where things stand.
Certification matters for a few specific reasons that go beyond just the quality of the installation. GAF Preferred and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status which we hold are manufacturer designations that require demonstrated installation expertise, verified insurance, and a documented track record of customer satisfaction. They also unlock access to enhanced manufacturer warranties that a non-certified contractor simply cannot offer you. If something fails on a roof installed by an uncertified contractor, you’re relying entirely on their word and their workmanship warranty assuming they’re still in business and reachable when the problem shows up.
In Short Hills specifically, where homes are architecturally complex and frequently feature premium materials, the skill gap between a certified roofing contractor and a general handyman is significant. Cedar shake installation, tile roofing, proper flashing around chimneys and dormers, and correct underlayment and ventilation systems all require specific training and experience. A handyman who installs roofs occasionally is not the same as a contractor who does it every day and is held to a manufacturer’s standard. For a home worth $2 million or more, the difference in who you hire is not a minor detail it’s the difference between a roof that performs for 20 years and one that gives you problems within three.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Short Hills
